Skip to main content

Lessons from a Raisin

Lessons from a raisin

If you've ever taken a Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) course, you may have done the famous raisin exercise. It's basically a  slow, methodical seeing, savoring of, and swallowing, a single raisin. 

Recently, I tried the activity with a class of eighth graders, and it was the most fun I've had in a long time. I'm not sure how much fun they had, though. 

I began by passing out a paper towel to each student, and told them we were going to do some eating for our brain break- a brief time each day when we practice some mindfulness together. The kids got excited and started to chatter. They probably had visions of chocolate shakes or maybe french fries. 

But when I told them that we were going to be eating a single raisin,  I saw disappointment cloud several faces. Some even let out audible groans of disgust. One boy looked like he might be sick. 

Several asked, "Do we have to do this?"  "No," I said, "you don't have to. Just  please be quiet so others can try this out." 

Several students decided to just sit and observe as I  had  other students pass out the raisins to the table groups. I began by reading a script from Mark Williams's book Mindfulness. As I went along, there were the usual comments and giggles. I didn't expect the silence of an adult setting, so I just tried to observe how they were reacting- to be curious- even as I tried to keep them focused and on task. 

When we were done, the sense of relief from the students was palpable. The activity of truly slowing down and tasting a single  raisin was more challenging for some than others. I asked for their feedback and reflection. I remembered that this wasn't about judging them, or imposing my ideas on how they  should have experienced eating their raisin. The reflection  was more about, What was this like for you?

One student said it was like "having her grandmother's finger in her mouth." Another said, "It was really good. It felt weird. But it was good." 

Two students  judged the experience without having even participated: "It sounded weird. I didn't do it, but if I did, it would have been gross." Another wrote, "It was very intense!! I didn't do it."

Another  mused, "I have never thought about my food before I have eaten it. I also have never taken a long time before I've put something in my mouth." 

And finally, another student wrote, "The raisin activity was something new. It made me really think about how detailed everything actually is."

I wrapped up by asking the class how the raisin exercise related to art class. A hand shot up immediately:  "It's like how we are seeing the details of the things we are drawing," one said. 


Like most learning activities, the takeaway was different for everyone. 

My lesson came from observing the variety of reactions that a single raisin could stir up- the shock and disappointment, the excitement and laughter, the emotional drama. The activity revealed our  human habit of judging events before we've even tried them, and of overreacting to, or exaggerating even the most mundane of our experiences. 

Just what you'd expect from middle schoolers.
  
And from all of us,  at times. 




















Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Exploration Day: Art from Within

                                                                                                                                                                        On Friday of this week, our entire school took a break from our normal schedule, and instituted a day of "exploration." Teachers were asked to prepare lessons outside of their normal curriculum, and we offered everything from mask-making  to "reading cafe," cooking, "Shrinky Dinks," one-act plays, thoughtful movie watching, and even a trip to the local police station (and much more). Although it was a ...

Working skillfully with the teenage mind

Mindfulness in the classroom sounds like a good idea on paper.  Take a break. Let kids breathe. Listen to the bell. Follow your thoughts. Simple, right?  Maybe... or maybe not.  Anyone who has worked with teenagers knows that even the best lesson plan can go awry, or that a teacher can encounter unexpected resistance from unexpected quarters. Then the teacher is dealing with the resistance of the student, and possibly,  their own irritation at the  student's "misbehavior." Resisting resistance! Jeremy Squires is a veteran social studies teacher at Highview, and recently shared how he deals with students who don't want to "follow the program" during mindfulness time (also called, "brain break").  Paradoxically, he found, by allowing kids to opt out of the exercise, it  gave  them permission to participate-while letting them save face in the process. His discovery  also reminds us of the self-consciousness that many kids feel at this age. He...

Twilight Zone Thinking

For our exploration day in June, I offered a class entitled, "The Twilight Zone and Philosophy." I have used an episode of the old Twilight Zone series in my humanities class, with some success, so I thought I'd expand on this idea for my explore class. I was not disappointed. In addition to watching a couple episodes of this classic TV series, I gave a very brief introduction to philosophy and we had some structured thinking exercises that related to the content of the videos.  When the morning of explore day came however, I was still a bit unsure how to start. I had my basic outline, and videos ready to go, but still didn't have that introductory "hook" that felt right. As I was scurrying to get ready, I was listening to a short history of the series on youtube. The narrator mentioned that the name of the series came from that time of day between the light and dark- the twilight. And that this was also a metaphor for that type of moral ambiguity or gra...