Skip to main content

Twilight Zone Thinking

For our exploration day in June, I offered a class entitled, "The Twilight Zone and Philosophy." I have used an episode of the old Twilight Zone series in my humanities class, with some success, so I thought I'd expand on this idea for my explore class. I was not disappointed. In addition to watching a couple episodes of this classic TV series, I gave a very brief introduction to philosophy and we had some structured thinking exercises that related to the content of the videos. 

When the morning of explore day came however, I was still a bit unsure how to start. I had my basic outline, and videos ready to go, but still didn't have that introductory "hook" that felt right. As I was scurrying to get ready, I was listening to a short history of the series on youtube. The narrator mentioned that the name of the series came from that time of day between the light and dark- the twilight. And that this was also a metaphor for that type of moral ambiguity or gray area, that we often encounter in life, and that philosophy students love. 

Bingo. I had my introduction. 

I would start by talking about two types of thinking. First, "black and white" thinking, where there is just one right answer to a problem, as in math or on a quiz; Second, "Twilight Zone" thinking, where things are ambiguous, where there are shades of gray- where there may be multiple truths and perspectives in a given situation. And after relating this to a general introduction to philosophy, we proceeded to do some "Twilight Zone" thinking- along with some great discussion. 

So why should middle schoolers be interested in this? Or anyone for that matter? Why spend time thinking about thinking? 

As cognitive psychology teaches us, the lenses we use to interpret reality greatly affect how we feel about and manage things. One common thinking error is called "black and white" thinking (also called "all- or -nothing" thinking.) Using this lens, things are either good or bad, or just one way, when in reality, life is often complex, and made up of seemingly contradictory elements- shades of gray. So instead of viewing a person or situation in just one way (eg, he's good, she's bad, he's a "jerk", etc), we work to see the nuances, the complexities that make up that person or situation. In Chinese philosophy, this was captured in the classic yin and yang symbol where opposites make up a interrelated whole. Dialectical therapy, or DBT, expresses a similar idea- that in any situation, multiple truths can coexist together at the same time, and all reflect some facet of reality.  
The yin and yang symbol 


And by adopting this lens, the lens of multiple truths, we can achieve  a more balanced reaction to life's inevitable complexities. 

A full exposition of thinking errors- formally called cognitive distortions-  is beyond the scope of this post, but if you are interested in learning more, I'd start with David Burn's book, Feeling Good, or any source on dialectical behavior therapy. 

What's great about the old Twilight Zone series is that it was full of morally ambiguous situations- perfect for a day of philosophical exploration. 






Comments

  1. IsabellaDecember 26, 2017 at 3:50 AM

    I think, It’s hard to manage our emotions and thoughts if we are not aware of what we’re thinking and feeling. So, it is not right for us. Our emotions can reveal what we value most, and we can then act on those values to evolve into our best selves — resilient, stable, curious, courageous, compassionate and empathetic.

    Criminal Thinking - Corrective thinking

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The conscious and connected student

While the mindfulness in education movement is still young, it has an increasing footprint in schools across the US and the globe. One can argue that most of the practices are body and sensory based practices- breathing, awareness of sound, mindful movement, etc. All in the service of self-awareness and emotional health, all well and good. But some educators are trying to expand that interpretation of mindfulness. Amy Edelstein is an educator in the Philadelphia schools where she has worked as an outside provider (meaning she is not a regular classroom teacher) teaching mindfulness to students for many years. She has developed her own program called  The Inner Strength System , and her most recent book is entitled, The Conscious Classroom (Emergence Education Press, 2017) . In this  wide-ranging book Edelstein shares her experience working in the urban schools of Philadelphia. She does not shy  away from describing the tremendous challenges her school f...
Post a Comment
Read more
I recently published my first book on Amazon, "Advice for Every Hour." It's available in both ebook and paperback. It has many of the essays on this blog, as well as additional content. It chronicles my adventures applying mindfulness and other strategies in my life, and classroom. 
Post a Comment
Read more

Playing Around

Photo by Matheo JBT on Unsplash In March I offered an e nso workshop for art teachers in my district. We had a great time that included discussion, mindful breathing,  lots of painting and generally making a mess of things. We talked about how enso painting fits into a Japanese aesthetic context, and how it is also relates to the "action painters" of abstract expressionism . Especially relevant is  the notion of   wabi-sabi ,  the embracing of change and imperfection.  We began the practice part of our workshop with some focused, mindful breathing, to help us become fully present. The silence was refreshing  after a very busy school day. I then demonstrated the traditional enso, where the artist completes a circle in  one focused movement. I also showed examples of ensos that I had done in other media, or combinations of media, to illustrate creative options for elaboration. After some practice on newsprint, my colleagues immediately began playing w...
Post a Comment
Read more