Skip to main content

The Watcher Within

I just finished a charming new book 
by Russ Roberts, entitled,
"How Adam Smith Can Change Your Life". It is a quick, fun read, and brings to life the ideas of Adam Smith, the Scottish philosopher who is best known for his classic work, "The Wealth of Nations." That book is considered the ultimate defense of the capitalist system, and an explication of how self -interest can be the invisible hand  that moves the economy. In this book however, Roberts focuses on a lesser known work of Smith's entitled, "The Theory of Moral Sentiments." While the Wealth of Nations focuses on the economic macrocosm, Moral Sentiments looks at the smaller circle of our relationships, and how we ought to behave to maximize those. 

Of most interest to mindful educators is his notion of the "impartial spectator." Smith notes how we have the ability to step back and look at our lives as if from a distance, as a spectator might watch a contest or game. This "meta-awareness" is perhaps our most human faculty, which separates us from all the other species. Not only can we watch ourselves in the moment, but we can project ourselves into the future, as we wish to be. This is very akin to mindfulness, where we can "step back" and view our thoughts and feelings as if from a distance, instead of being immediately identified or "caught up with" them. 

According to Jack Russell Weinstein of the University of North Dakota, 

"The impartial spectator is the anthropomorphization of the calm and disinterested self that can be recovered with self control and self reflection. In today's world, someone might advise us to "take a deep breath and step back" from a given situation in order to reflect on our actions more dispassionately."

Mindfulness, broadly speaking, is not only about calm or stress relief. It is also about this type of perspective and self-reflection, that can come about only by stopping, and looking inward. And for Smith, the impartial spectator includes the ethical reflection that is so necessary to develop in a mature and mindful person. Many thanks to author Russ Roberts for putting out this engaging  and fascinating read. 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The conscious and connected student

While the mindfulness in education movement is still young, it has an increasing footprint in schools across the US and the globe. One can argue that most of the practices are body and sensory based practices- breathing, awareness of sound, mindful movement, etc. All in the service of self-awareness and emotional health, all well and good. But some educators are trying to expand that interpretation of mindfulness. Amy Edelstein is an educator in the Philadelphia schools where she has worked as an outside provider (meaning she is not a regular classroom teacher) teaching mindfulness to students for many years. She has developed her own program called  The Inner Strength System , and her most recent book is entitled, The Conscious Classroom (Emergence Education Press, 2017) . In this  wide-ranging book Edelstein shares her experience working in the urban schools of Philadelphia. She does not shy  away from describing the tremendous challenges her school f...
I recently published my first book on Amazon, "Advice for Every Hour." It's available in both ebook and paperback. It has many of the essays on this blog, as well as additional content. It chronicles my adventures applying mindfulness and other strategies in my life, and classroom. 

Embracing your life

I met Tom Odland my freshman year at St. Olaf college in 1977. He was a typical college kid, full of life and had a great sense of humor. He was a talented trumpet player too, and was always after  me to sit and listen to his latest jazz hero. (He was part of  a small band that played Mexican and traditional rock music which I remember dancing to and having a ball.) Tom eventually left St. Olaf, to continue his studies at the University of Minnesota, eventually becoming a successful research scientist for St. Jude's Medical for ten years. After that, he worked for a German medical company and later, went on his own as a consultant.  He was happily married, with a wife and four  daughters, when tragedy struck.  While fixing a toilet one day,  he realized something was going terribly wrong. When he tried to grasp a plunger with his right arm, he couldn't hold it. With his knowledge of biology, he figured he was having a stroke.  By some miracle, he...